SIP-6: Renaming SUICIDE opcode
| Authors | Hudson Jameson <hudson@hudsonjameson.com> |
|---|---|
| Created | 2015-11-22 |
Table of Contents
Abstract
The solution proposed in this SIP is to change the name of the SUICIDE opcode in Sila programming languages with SELFDESTRUCT.
Motivation
Mental health is a very real issue for many people and small notions can make a difference. Those dealing with loss or depression would benefit from not seeing the word suicide in our programming languages. By some estimates, 350 million people worldwide suffer from depression. The semantics of Sila’s programming languages need to be reviewed often if we wish to grow our ecosystem to all types of developers.
An Sila security audit commissioned by DEVolution, GmbH and performed by Least Authority recommended the following:
Replace the instruction name “suicide” with a less connotative word like “self-destruct”, “destroy”, “terminate”, or “close”, especially since that is a term describing the natural conclusion of a contract.
The primary reason for us to change the term suicide is to show that people matter more than code and Sila is a mature enough of a project to recognize the need for a change. Suicide is a heavy subject and we should make every effort possible to not affect those in our development community who suffer from depression or who have recently lost someone to suicide. Sila is a young platform and it will cause less headaches if we implement this change early on in its life.
Implementation
SELFDESTRUCT is added as an alias of SUICIDE opcode (rather than replacing it).
https://github.com/sila-chain/solidity/commit/a8736b7b271dac117f15164cf4d2dfabcdd2c6fd
https://github.com/sila-chain/serpent/commit/1106c3bdc8f1bd9ded58a452681788ff2e03ee7c
Citation
Please cite this document as:
Hudson Jameson <hudson@hudsonjameson.com>, "SIP-6: Renaming SUICIDE opcode," Sila Improvement Proposals, no. 6, November 2015. Available: https://sips.sila.org/SIPS/sip-6.